Nuin Co manufactures a number of different components for the oil industry. The management is considering whether to buy in or continue making one of the components (component A). This component currently has a manufacturing cost as follows:

$

Direct labour (4hr @ $12ph)

48

Direct materials

24

Variable overheads (4hr @ $2ph)

8

Fixed overheads (4hr @ $5ph)

20

100 per unit

The direct labour, direct materials and variable overhead costs all relate directly to the production of component A and would not be incurred if production of the component stopped. However, the fixed overheads charge is an apportionment of costs which would still be incurred even if component A were not produced.

Required:

Under each of the three (separate) situations below, advise the management of Nuin Co whether component A should be bought in or made in house:

(a) The purchasing manager has found an external manufacturer that can supply the component A at a guaranteed price of $90 per unit.

(b) The external supplier can offer component A at $90 per unit. If Nuin Co continues to manufacture component A in house, it will need to install new computer controlled manufacturing systems which will have a fixed cost of $50,000 per year.

(C) The external supplier can offer component A at $90 per unit. The manufacture of component A in house requires the use of specialist skilled direct labour. If component A were bought in, that direct labour could be used in the production of component B which is sold for $180 and has a manufacturing cost as follows:

$

Direct labour (8hr @ $12ph)

96

Direct materials

18

Variable overheads (8hr @ $2ph)

16

Fixed overheads (8hr @ $5ph)

40

170 per unit